
Point with one finger
People say hip for a surprisingly wide area, from the belt line to the top of the thigh, and the name matters less than the spot. Stand up and put one finger on the place that hurts most as you walk. Then see whether it lands in the crease at the front, on the bony point at the side, or further back in the buttock.
A problem in the hip joint itself tends to be felt deep and low at the front, often in the groin, and it can also be felt in the thigh or even the knee, which is why a sore knee that looks normal is sometimes worth a look one joint higher. Past middle age the usual reason is osteoarthritis. In younger, active adults the shape of the joint or its rim is more often in question.
What the step itself tells you
The timing of the pain does not name the cause, but it narrows the field.
- Sore for the first few steps after sitting, then looser: a stiff joint or a tendon that has been still. Both behave like this.
- Fine at first, building with distance: something loaded again and again, in the joint or in the tendons beside it.
- Worse on stairs and hills: the muscles at the side and back of the hip work harder, and the groin joins in if the joint is the problem.
- Worse on a sloping pavement or soft sand: the hips are loaded unevenly, so one that copes on the flat can hurt on a camber.
- Coming on after a certain distance and easing when you sit or lean on a trolley: look at the lower back rather than the hip. Narrowing around the nerves there, the usual pattern behind lower back pain when walking, tends to ease with bending forward, which is why leaning on the trolley helps.
A limp that you or somebody else has noticed, or a hip that catches or gives way, belongs in an assessment sooner.
The side of the hip
Pain on the bony point at the side, which is sore to lie on at night, is the territory of the gluteal tendons and the sac beside them. It tends to be worse on stairs and when standing on one leg, because both load the same tendons. The tendons matter as much as the sac, and hip bursitis and outer hip pain goes into why.
Buttock pain on a walk has the most candidates
The lower back and its nerves can send pain into the buttock. So can the sacroiliac joint at the back of the pelvis, the deep hip muscles, and the hamstring tendon where it anchors to the sit bone, where sit bone pain tends to show on hard seats and on a long stride uphill. What separates them is what else changes the pain: bending, sitting, coughing, lying on one side, or pressing a particular spot. Pain that spreads below the knee, with tingling or numbness, is a nerve question and a back one, and that is the sciatica picture. Buttock or thigh pain that arrives at the same distance each time and fades when you simply stand still can be poor circulation, which goes to a GP.
Watching you walk, then testing what you cannot see
An assessment starts with the story: where, at what point in the step, after how far, and what else changes it. Then it watches you walk, because the way a hip is carried says a good deal. A pelvis that tips instead of staying level, or a shorter step on one side, can be seen from across a room.
After that come the movements of the hip, the strength of the muscles around it, the lower back, and sensation and reflexes in the leg. Imaging is requested when clinically indicated, and it comes up more readily for a groin ache that has been stiff for months, or a hip that became painful after a fall, than for a sore spot on the side.
Where you feel it, and where an assessment starts
Each spot has a few likely suspects, and two can be sore together; a sore hip is often a mixture. Where it lands is where an assessment starts.
- Deep in the groin or the crease at the front
- Leans towards the hip joint itself, often stiff after rest and sometimes felt in the inner thigh or the knee.
- On the bony point at the side, sore to lie on
- Leans towards the tendons and sac at the side of the hip, and is worse on stairs and standing on one leg.
- Low in the buttock, under the dimple of the pelvis
- Can point to the sacroiliac joint or the lower back, and the two are hard to separate by feel alone.
- Deep in the middle of the buttock, worse sitting
- Fits the deep hip muscles, the lower back or the sit bone, so sitting and walking are compared.
- On the sit bone, or just below it
- Often the hamstring tendon where it attaches to the pelvis, and a hard seat or a hill can bring it on.
- Across the front of the thigh, with no groin ache
- Points to the muscles at the front of the hip, or to a nerve higher up in the lower back.
- Starts after much the same distance each time, eased by sitting or leaning forward
- Looks towards the lower back, where the space around the nerves can narrow as you stand and walk.
- Down the whole leg, with tingling or numbness
- A nerve is involved, which is the sciatica picture, and the leg gets its own sensation, strength and reflex tests.
When to get it looked at
Go to a hospital emergency department straight away if you have numbness or altered feeling around the saddle area, meaning the groin, the inner thighs, the buttocks or the genitals; a loss of normal sensation in the genitals, including during sex; trouble starting to pass urine, or any new change in your bladder or bowel control; weakness in both legs, particularly if it is getting worse; new or worsening pain running down both legs; weakness in one leg that is severe or getting worse, or a foot that has started to catch or drag when you walk; or numbness in a leg that is spreading or getting worse quickly.
Go to a hospital emergency department straight away for back or neck pain after a serious fall or a high-impact accident, such as a car accident; back or neck pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell; or new back or neck pain if your immune system is weakened, for instance by long-term steroids or chemotherapy, if you inject drugs, or if you have recently had a spinal injection, spinal surgery or a dental procedure.
A hip that is hot, swollen and very painful, any hip pain with a fever, or being unable to put weight on the leg after a fall means a hospital emergency department straight away.
A bulge in the groin that turns hard and painful goes to an emergency department. One that appears when you cough or stand, or groin pain with a general feeling of being unwell, is a question for a GP rather than a hip assessment. A deep groin ache that gets worse with every step, especially after a sudden jump in running or walking or with long-term steroid use, can be a problem in the bone itself, so see a GP promptly and ease off until then.
Go to a hospital emergency department the same day if you have new clumsiness in both hands, or new unsteadiness on your feet.
See your GP promptly, before booking here, if you have a history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, pain at night that will not settle in any position, known osteoporosis with new severe pain, numbness that is spreading or getting worse slowly, or new, unexplained back pain as an older adult.
When walks are getting shorter, when a limp has appeared, or when a few weeks of gentler loops and a slower pace have not shifted the pain, that is the point to have it assessed. Pain from the joint, the tendons and the lower back can land in the same spot, so each is looked at before any one is blamed.

