The Back & Spine Clinic, Chiropractic Clinic
Menu

Suite 1, Lower Ground Floor, 225 Macquarie Street
Sydney NSW 2000

02 9037 0769info@thebackandspineclinic.com.au
02 9037 0769Book

How the spine works

Modic changes: three kinds of marrow change beside a disc

Modic changes are changes in the bone marrow next to a disc, described on an MRI and sorted into three types by how they look. Some of what they mean is agreed, and whether they cause pain is still argued over.

Marrow in the bone beside the disc

Inside each vertebra is marrow, a soft, spongy tissue that fills the spaces in the bone. The part of it that lies right against a disc, just under the endplate, is where Modic changes are found. The name comes from the radiologist who sorted them into types in the late 1980s, and it has stuck, though some reports write only endplate changes.

The changes are described on MRI and not on an X-ray, because an X-ray shows dense bone and very little of the soft marrow inside it. The scan is requested when clinically indicated, and a Modic change is usually found alongside other findings in the same disc rather than on its own.

The bone marrow beside a lumbar disc, seen from the side← FrontBack →L4Marrow bythe discDiscL5

Two lumbar vertebrae, L4 above L5, seen from the left side with the front of the body on the left, and the disc between them. The soft marrow inside each vertebral body, in the strip right against the disc, is highlighted. That strip is where Modic changes sit.

L4 and L5 from the side, front to the left. Modic changes show up in the strips of marrow just above and just below the disc.

Two pictures of one slice

The three types are told apart by comparing two MRI pictures of the same slice. They are called T1 and T2, and the simplest way to think of them is as the same photograph taken with the contrast set differently. On one, fat looks bright and fluid looks dark. On the other, fluid looks bright. A change in marrow shows up differently on each, and the pattern across the pair is what gives the type.

This is why a report quoting a type is not guessing. It is reading a pattern on two pictures. A report that does not sort the pattern may simply say endplate changes and stop there.

What is agreed

There is broad agreement on the description. Modic changes are changes in marrow signal beside an endplate, they are usually found next to a disc that has also altered, and they are sorted into three types by appearance. Type 1 is known to turn toward type 2 on later scans. And they are found in backs that hurt and in backs that do not.

There is also agreement that a type 1 change can look at first like an infection of the disc and the bone beside it, and a radiologist will usually say if a picture points that way. If your report raises infection, take it back to whoever ordered the scan the same day. A true infection can bring a fever, a feeling of being unwell and pain that is there at rest. Back pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell goes to a hospital emergency department straight away, and pain at night that will not settle in any position goes to your GP promptly. None of that is what a Modic change on its own describes.

What is still debated

Whether these changes cause pain is not settled. Type 1 changes have been linked with pain in some people, while others with the same picture have none, so the finding cannot be named as the explanation for a sore back. Why they form is also argued over. Candidates include strain on the endplate, a reaction to disc breakdown, inflammation and, more contested still, a slow, low-grade bacterial presence in the disc, which is a different thing from the disc and bone infection a type 1 change can look like. Each has its supporters.

Nor is it settled whether any particular course of care should follow from a Modic change, so be wary of anyone who sounds certain. What can be said is smaller. The finding is a piece of the picture. It earns weight when it lies at the level that is sore and the examination agrees.

Reading the word against your back

Set beside your back, a Modic line is one clue among several. Does the sore level match the level on the report? Does loading the spine bring the pain on, and does anything travel into a leg? The neighbours in the same paragraph of the report count too. One is Schmorl’s nodes, a different endplate finding that can sit close to a Modic change. Another is disc desiccation, the water-content change that tends to travel with it.

The two questions worth asking of any Modic line are which type it is and which level it names, and whoever ordered the scan can answer both. A Modic line is also one entry in a long spine MRI report, and a report is written to be complete rather than to rank what matters.

Types 1, 2 and 3 compared

Each type is a pattern across the two pictures. The descriptions are of an image, and a report may name more than one type at a level.

Type 1
Dark on the T1 picture and bright on the T2. Read as extra fluid and an inflammation-like change in the marrow. It is the type the debate about pain mostly centres on.
Type 2
Bright on both pictures. Read as marrow that has taken on more fat. It is described as the more settled pattern, and type 1 can turn toward it over time.
Type 3
Dark on both pictures. Read as dense, hardened bone beside the endplate, often called sclerosis. It is described less often than the other two.
Mixed type 1 and 2
Both patterns at one level. A report may use this when the picture is in transition, or when different parts of the same endplate look different.
Endplate changes
A looser phrase that may stand for a Modic change when the type was not worked out. Ask which type it is, and you will usually get a more specific answer.

When to get it looked at

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away if you have numbness or altered feeling around the saddle area, meaning the groin, the inner thighs, the buttocks or the genitals; a loss of normal sensation in the genitals, including during sex; trouble starting to pass urine, or any new change in your bladder or bowel control; weakness in both legs, particularly if it is getting worse; new or worsening pain running down both legs; weakness in one leg that is severe or getting worse, or a foot that has started to catch or drag when you walk; or numbness in a leg that is spreading or getting worse quickly.

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away for back or neck pain after a serious fall or a high-impact accident, such as a car accident; back or neck pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell; or new back or neck pain if your immune system is weakened, for instance by long-term steroids or chemotherapy, if you inject drugs, or if you have recently had a spinal injection, spinal surgery or a dental procedure.

Go to a hospital emergency department the same day if you have new clumsiness in both hands, or new unsteadiness on your feet.

See your GP promptly, before booking here, if you have a history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, pain at night that will not settle in any position, known osteoporosis with new severe pain, numbness that is spreading or getting worse slowly, or new, unexplained back pain as an older adult.

Back pain that has hung around for months, or keeps coming back whenever you load it, is a good reason to come in with a Modic line on your report. So is wanting the word explained by someone looking at your back rather than at a screen. Bring the type and the level with you.

If you want it looked at

An assessment starts with what you have noticed and when, then tests on the nerves, muscles and joints your symptoms point to, with what we find explained the same day.

Everyone moves through this differently, so the plan is paced to your body, reviewed with you as you progress, not read off a fixed schedule of visits.

Common questions

Is Modic type 1 the same as an infection?

No. Type 1 describes extra fluid and an inflammation-like change in the marrow beside a disc, and it is usually read as part of disc degeneration. It can look like a disc infection at first, and a radiologist usually says when a picture points that way. If yours does, take the report back to whoever ordered the scan the same day. Back pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell goes to an emergency department straight away.

Can Modic changes go away or change type?

They can change over time. Type 1 is described as turning toward type 2 on later images, and a report that compares two dates may say progressed or converted. A change on the picture is not a measure of how you feel, and the two do not always move together.

Do Modic changes explain my back pain?

They may sit at the level that hurts, and for some people they seem to belong to the picture. They also appear on the images of people with no pain at all, so a report cannot make that call alone. The call comes from your story, the examination and whether the level on the report matches the level that is sore.

Why does my MRI say endplate changes and not Modic?

Many reports use the plain phrase for the same area, sometimes without naming the type. If you would like to know the type, ask the person who requested the scan, because the type is the part that carries information. If it was not sorted, the rest of the report can still be read with the examination.

Take the first step towards better movement.

Suite 1, Lower Ground Floor, 225 Macquarie Street, Sydney NSW 2000. No referral needed to book.