The Back & Spine Clinic, Chiropractic Clinic
Menu

Suite 1, Lower Ground Floor, 225 Macquarie Street
Sydney NSW 2000

02 9037 0769info@thebackandspineclinic.com.au
02 9037 0769Book

Back pain

Do I need a new mattress for my back pain?

A mattress for back pain: what firmness changes, how to tell whether the bed is the problem, and how long to give a new one before you decide.

Often not, and not first. A mattress can change how comfortable a sore back is overnight, but the bed is rarely the whole story. It is worth suspecting when the stiffness is worst on waking and different in another bed, and less likely when the back hurts the same wherever you sleep.

A practitioner holding a full spine and pelvis model out toward a seated woman, his free hand shaping the movement he is describing.
A flexible spine and pelvis model, held out in one hand.

What a mattress can and cannot change

A mattress decides how far each part of you sinks. The widest and heaviest parts of you, the hips and the shoulders, press in further than the waist and the small of the back, and the mattress either fills that difference or it does not. Too soft, and the heaviest part sinks furthest and holds the spine in a curve it would not choose. Too hard, and the body rests on a few bony points with gaps left underneath the rest. So the old idea that a sore back needs the hardest bed you can find does not follow: a harder bed swaps one problem for the other.

That is the whole of its job. A mattress cannot change what is irritating the back; it can only change how much the night adds to it. A back that is sore from a day of sitting or lifting is likely to be sore on any bed, while a bed that has gone lumpy can pile something extra onto a back that was already sore. Working out which of those you are dealing with is the useful question.

What firmness changes, and why the label tells you so little

Firmness is how much a surface resists you, and there is no common scale for it. One maker’s medium-firm is another’s firm, and a mattress that feels firm to a light person can feel soft to a heavy one, because weight decides how far you sink. A label cannot tell you what a bed will do under your body, and nobody else can either, because the answer depends on how you lie on it.

What firmness changes is the shape your spine holds. Lying on your side on a bed that is too hard, the hip and shoulder are pushed up and the waist is left unsupported; on one that is too soft, the hip drops below the waist. Lying on your back, the question is whether the small of the back is supported or left hanging in a hollow.

The shape to look for is the one you hold standing, with gentle curves and no sideways bend. In a shop, lie on your side and have someone look from behind: the line from the back of your head to your tailbone should look roughly straight. Lie on your back and notice whether the small of your back is held lightly or pushed up into a deeper arch. Do it for several minutes in the position you actually sleep in, not for ten seconds seated on the edge.

Is the bed the problem? Four ways to find out

Test the bed you have before you replace it.

  • Sleep somewhere else for a few nights. A spare bed or a hotel room will do. If the mornings change, the bed is a suspect. If they come with you, the question points at the back instead.
  • Look for a hollow. Lay a long, straight object such as a broom handle across the mattress where you sleep and look along it at mattress level. A dip under the hips, or a lumpy patch, means the surface has worn.
  • Check the timing. Stiffness from a night in an unhelpful position tends to be worst in the first minutes and to clear as you move about. Pain that builds through the day is pointing somewhere else. Two things are not the mattress’s doing, and a GP is the first call for both: stiffness that is still there after half an hour on most mornings for weeks, and pain that wakes you and will not settle in any position. For making sense of a stiff start to the day, see back pain after sleeping.
  • Try the smaller change first. A topper, which is a softer or firmer layer over the mattress you have, or a firm board slid under a sagging mattress, changes the surface without a whole new bed. Either is worth a trial before you commit to a replacement.

If you do buy one, how long to give it

The body takes time to get used to any new surface, so the first nights on a different bed can feel odd even when it suits you. A fair trial is a few weeks, not a few nights. Jot down how stiff you are when you first stand and how often the back wakes you, and set those notes beside the ones you made on the old bed before the change.

Read the returns terms before the firmness label. A trial period you can return the bed from is worth more than any description, because it lets you find out what the bed does to your back rather than what the shop says it does. If two of you share the bed, test it together, lying down at the same time in your usual positions. A difference in weight changes how far each of you sinks, and a bed that suits one of you can leave the other hanging.

The way you lie and your pillows also matter: see sleeping positions for back pain and choosing a pillow for neck pain.

A bed is for sleeping, and the day still counts

Lying down is appealing when the back is sore, and a comfortable mattress can make it more so. The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners’ Handbook of Non-Drug Interventions (2019) advises staying active instead of resting in bed for a low back pain episode of less than six weeks, and by that it means ordinary daily activity, work included. The mattress is for the hours of sleep. It is not a reason to spend the other hours on it.

When the bed is the question, an assessment begins with the pattern of the pain: when it is worst, what it does through the day and whether a night elsewhere changes it. The examination then tests which positions of the spine bring it on, and a few questions rule out causes that have nothing to do with the bed. Bring your morning notes. If your back hurts through the day, whichever bed it spends the night in, start with lower back pain.

What the guidelines say

When to get it looked at

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away if you have numbness or altered feeling around the saddle area, meaning the groin, the inner thighs, the buttocks or the genitals; a loss of normal sensation in the genitals, including during sex; trouble starting to pass urine, or any new change in your bladder or bowel control; weakness in both legs, particularly if it is getting worse; new or worsening pain running down both legs; weakness in one leg that is severe or getting worse, or a foot that has started to catch or drag when you walk; or numbness in a leg that is spreading or getting worse quickly.

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away for back or neck pain after a serious fall or a high-impact accident, such as a car accident; back or neck pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell; or new back or neck pain if your immune system is weakened, for instance by long-term steroids or chemotherapy, if you inject drugs, or if you have recently had a spinal injection, spinal surgery or a dental procedure.

Go to a hospital emergency department the same day if you have new clumsiness in both hands, or new unsteadiness on your feet.

See your GP promptly, before booking here, if you have a history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, pain at night that will not settle in any position, known osteoporosis with new severe pain, numbness that is spreading or getting worse slowly, or new, unexplained back pain as an older adult.

Booking an assessment makes sense if the mornings stay sore whichever bed you sleep in, if your back wakes you most nights but settles when you shift, or if a new mattress has had a fair trial and nothing has changed.

Take the first step towards better movement.

Macquarie Street, Sydney. No referral needed to book.