The Back & Spine Clinic, Chiropractic Clinic
Menu

Suite 1, Lower Ground Floor, 225 Macquarie Street
Sydney NSW 2000

02 9037 0769info@thebackandspineclinic.com.au
02 9037 0769Book

Neck and headaches

Which pillow is right for neck pain?

Pillow height is set by your shoulder width and the side you sleep on, not the label. A folded towel test to try before buying a pillow for neck pain.

The right pillow keeps your head level with the rest of your spine in the position you sleep in. Its height is set by the width of your shoulder and the side you lie on, not by the label, and you can find it at home with a folded towel before you spend anything.

The skull, neck, collarbones and upper ribcage of a teaching skeleton, centred on flat grey.
Skull, neck and collarbones of a teaching skeleton, front view.

Why the gap between your ear and the mattress matters

Lying on your side, your shoulder holds your ear up off the mattress, by roughly the distance from the side of your neck to the tip of your shoulder. The pillow’s job is to fill that gap. Too low, and the head sags towards the bed, bending the neck sideways. Too high, and the head is propped up, bending the neck the other way. Either way the muscles on one side hold a bent neck for hours.

So the height is a measurement, not a choice between soft and firm. Broad shoulders need a taller pillow than narrow ones, and a pillow that suits a side sleeper is usually too tall for someone on their back.

Lying on your back there is no shoulder in the way. The head needs a lower pillow that holds it level and fills the curve behind the neck without tucking the chin towards the chest. Lying on your front, the neck is turned to one side for the whole night whatever the pillow does, so the pillow there should be as thin as you can tolerate, or absent.

A folded towel test to try before you spend anything

Shops sell height as a feature, with labels such as low and high. You can find your own number at home with some towels and a phone propped at mattress height. Do it on your own bed, because a soft mattress lets the shoulder sink and calls for less height than a firm one.

  1. Fold bath towels into flat rectangles about as wide as a pillow, and stack a few. Press the stack down with your hand first, because a pillow compresses under a head too.
  2. Lie on the side you sleep on most, with the stack under your head in place of a pillow, and your arms and legs where they usually go.
  3. Ask someone to look from behind, or prop a phone behind you and film for half a minute. The line from the back of your head down the middle of your spine should look straight, not bent towards the mattress or away from it.
  4. Add or remove a towel until it does. Measure the stack with a ruler and write the height down. That number is what you take to a shop.
  5. Repeat on your back with a thinner stack, and a small rolled towel under the curve of your neck. Write that height down too.

If a stack brings on pain or tingling down an arm, come off it and leave the test there. Weakness in one arm that is severe or getting worse, or numbness in an arm that is spreading or getting worse quickly, means a hospital emergency department straight away. Short of that, pins and needles, numbness or weakness in an arm or hand is one for your GP, promptly.

A printed height is the height before you lie on the pillow. Memory foam sinks slowly and keeps the shape of your head, while feather and fibre fills sink quickly and can be plumped. None of these is wrong. What matters is the height under your head once it has settled, and a pillow with a removable layer lets you adjust that until it matches your number.

Contoured pillows, and the arm under the pillow

A contoured pillow, often sold as a cervical pillow or a neck support pillow, has a raised edge for the neck and a dip for the head. It is a way of building the height into a shaped block, and it only fits if the raised part matches your number. Some come in sizes for exactly that reason. With your towel heights written down, you can check a shaped pillow against them in a shop, lying on it in your usual position for several minutes rather than sitting on the edge of the bed.

Side sleepers have one more variable, the arm underneath. An arm tucked under the pillow raises the head further and leaves the shoulder bearing weight, so a pillow that was the right height can start to feel too tall. Bring the lower arm out in front of you instead and test again.

Waking with numb hands at night is not the same question as a stiff neck. It tends to follow how the wrists and elbows were bent during sleep more than the height of the pillow, so a new pillow is not the first thing to change. Pins and needles, numbness or weakness in an arm or hand is also one for your GP, promptly.

How long to give a new pillow, and when the pillow is not the problem

A neck used to a very tall pillow can feel odd for the first nights on a lower one, even when the lower one is the right height. Give the new height a few nights before you judge it, and if it still feels wrong, go back to the stack you measured and adjust by a single towel. If you have bought a pillow, keep the returns terms until you are sure.

A pillow is unlikely to be the whole story for a neck that is sore after a day at a screen, or one that locks on waking so that it will not turn to one side. That second one is usually called wry neck. For the first, there are gentle neck stretches for a stiff neck to try.

The pillow is only one part of the bed. Below the neck, it is worth thinking about sleeping positions for back pain and the pillows that go with them.

What an assessment looks at for a neck that is sore on waking

The questions at an assessment start with the pattern: which side you sleep on, when the neck is at its worst, whether it eases through the morning, and whether anything travels into the shoulder or the arm. The examination looks at how far the neck turns and tilts each way and which movements bring the pain on. It also looks at how the upper back and shoulders move, and tests the nerves to the arm if there are arm symptoms. Pillow height is one more detail alongside that.

If the neck hurts for reasons that have nothing to do with the bed, neck pain is the place to start.

When to get it looked at

Call an ambulance if there is any confusion, sudden weakness or numbness in the face, arm or leg on one side, facial drooping, slurred speech, sudden trouble speaking, seeing or understanding, loss of vision, a seizure, or a sudden loss of balance or coordination.

Call an ambulance or go to a hospital emergency department straight away if a headache comes on suddenly and severely (the worst you have ever had), if a headache arrives with fever, a stiff neck or a rash, or if a headache follows a knock to the head.

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away for back or neck pain after a serious fall or a high-impact accident, such as a car accident; back or neck pain with a fever or feeling generally unwell; or new back or neck pain if your immune system is weakened, for instance by long-term steroids or chemotherapy, if you inject drugs, or if you have recently had a spinal injection, spinal surgery or a dental procedure.

Go to a hospital emergency department straight away if you have weakness in one arm that is severe or getting worse, or numbness in an arm that is spreading or getting worse quickly.

Go to a hospital emergency department the same day if you have new clumsiness in both hands, or new unsteadiness on your feet.

See your GP promptly, before booking here, if you have pins and needles, numbness or weakness in an arm or hand, a history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, pain at night that will not settle in any position, or known osteoporosis with new severe pain.

A neck that is still stiff on waking after the pillow has been changed, that keeps locking to one side, or that brings on a headache of the kind you already know is worth an assessment, which can look at the neck and upper back directly rather than at the bedding.

Take the first step towards better movement.

Macquarie Street, Sydney. No referral needed to book.